Pantiles vs Plain Roof Tiles: All You Need To Know

Introducing Types Of Roof Tiles

Choosing the right roof tile can shape the appearance of a building for generations. Whether you are restoring a listed property, specifying materials for a new development, replacing an existing roof, or planning a self-build home, it is important to understand how different types of roof tiles vary in style, character, and suitability.

When comparing pantiles vs plain tiles, the most noticeable difference is their shape. Pantiles have a curved profile that creates a flowing, textured roofscape, while plain tiles offer a flatter, more layered appearance. Both have a long history in British architecture and remain popular choices for heritage properties and character-led new builds.

What Are Pantiles?

Pantiles are traditional clay roof tiles with a distinctive S-shaped profile. Their curved design creates natural movement across the roof, with areas of light and shadow adding depth and character.

Historically, pantiles have been widely used across the East of England, Lincolnshire, Yorkshire, and coastal areas. They are particularly well suited to cottages, barns, farm buildings, rural homes, and properties where the roof forms an important part of the local architectural style.

The curved shape also has a practical purpose, helping to direct rainwater down the roof. When laid together, the tiles create a durable and attractive roof covering with a strong regional identity.

William Blyth produces two handmade pantile ranges: ‘Barco’ Old English Pantiles and Lincoln Pantiles. Our ‘Barco’ Old English Pantiles have a gently curved profile, while Lincoln Pantiles have a deeper pan and bolder roll for a more pronounced finish.

What Are Plain Tiles?

Plain tiles are smaller, flat clay roof tiles laid in overlapping courses. This creates a neat, layered roof covering that feels traditional, balanced, and understated.

Because of their simple shape and smaller format, plain clay roof tiles are highly versatile. They can be used across straightforward roof slopes as well as more detailed areas such as hips, valleys, dormers, and roof junctions. They are commonly found on cottages, churches, period homes, estate buildings, and properties within conservation areas.

William Blyth offers three distinct plain tile ranges. Our Handmade Plain Tiles provide rich texture and natural variation. Traditional Sanded Plain Tiles have a softer, weathered appearance that can help reflect the character of reclaimed tiles. Our Classic Range Tiles provide a practical handmade option with a traditional finish and good availability.

Pantiles vs Plain Tiles: What Is The Difference?

The key difference between pantiles and plain tiles is their profile.

Pantiles create a more sculptural roofscape. Their curves introduce visible movement and shadow, making them an attractive choice for buildings that suit a warm, rustic, or regionally distinctive appearance.

Plain tiles create a more uniform and refined finish. Their layered arrangement works well across a wide variety of architectural styles, from traditional cottages to more formal period properties and carefully designed new builds.

The way the tiles are laid also differs. Pantiles are larger and shaped to interlock visually across the roof. Plain tiles are smaller and installed in overlapping courses, which can make them especially suitable for detailed roof forms.

Neither option is inherently better than the other. The right choice depends on the building, its location, the roof pitch, the surrounding architecture, and any planning or conservation requirements.

Which Roof Tiles Are Best For Heritage Buildings?

For listed buildings and properties in conservation areas, the most appropriate roof tile is usually the one that respects the original building and its setting.

In some areas, traditional clay pantiles are an important part of the local landscape. In others, plain tiles may provide a more historically accurate finish. Architects, surveyors, conservation officers, and heritage bodies will often consider the existing roof covering, neighbouring properties, and regional building traditions before specifying a replacement tile.

Handmade clay roof tiles are particularly valuable in heritage settings because each tile has its own subtle character. Natural differences in colour, texture, and shape help a new roof settle into its surroundings without appearing overly uniform.

William Blyth’s tiles are handmade using Humber clay from our own reserves, following traditional methods that preserve this natural variation.

Are Pantiles Or Plain Tiles Suitable For New Builds?

Pantiles and plain tiles are not limited to restoration work. Both can bring character and long-life performance to new homes and developments.

Pantiles work particularly well on properties designed to reflect rural or regional architecture. Their curved profile can soften the appearance of a new roof and help a building feel established within its surroundings.

Plain tiles offer a versatile choice for both traditional and contemporary designs. Their clean, layered finish works well on individual homes, premium developments, and projects where the roof needs to complement an existing streetscape.

For self-builders and private homeowners, choosing between pantiles vs plain tiles is often as much about personal preference as technical requirements. A roof is one of the most visible features of a property, so it is worth considering how the material will look as it naturally weathers over time.

How To Choose Between Pantiles And Plain Tiles

When considering different types of roof tiles, begin with the architectural character of the building. A traditional cottage, rural barn, listed property, or new development may each require a different approach.

Pantiles may be the right choice if you are looking for a curved tile with visible depth, movement, and regional character. Plain tiles may be more suitable if you want a classic, layered finish that can adapt to detailed roof shapes and a broad range of architectural styles.

Technical considerations are equally important. The roof pitch, layout, planning conditions, and installation requirements should always be reviewed with your architect, surveyor, roofer, or conservation officer where appropriate.

Explore The William Blyth Roof Tile Range

At William Blyth, we have been producing handmade clay roof tiles since 1840. Our range includes ‘Barco’ Old English Pantiles, Lincoln Pantiles, Handmade Plain Tiles, Traditional Sanded Plain Tiles, and Classic Range Tiles.

For projects requiring an alternative profile, we also produce Celtic Tiles and Corrugated Tiles, offering further options beyond traditional pantiles and plain tiles.

Every William Blyth roof tile is shaped with care to create natural colour variation, rich texture, and lasting character. From sensitive heritage restorations to carefully considered new builds, our handmade clay tiles are crafted for buildings where the roof deserves close attention.

Request A Roof Tile Sample

The best way to compare pantiles and plain tiles is to see and feel the tiles in person. Request a William Blyth roof tile sample to explore the colour, texture, and handmade finish of our ranges, or contact our team to discuss the right tile for your project.